Un Estudio Longitudinal de la Reputación Social no Conformista y la Violencia en Adolescentes desde la Perspectiva de Género

Moreno Ruiz, David; Jesus, Saul Neves de; Murgui Pérez, Sergio; Martínez Ferrer, Belén

doi:10.5093/in2012v21n1a6

Vol. 21. Num. 1. - 2012. Pages 67-75

<< Previous

Next >>

Un Estudio Longitudinal de la Reputación Social no Conformista y la Violencia en Adolescentes desde la Perspectiva de Género

[A Longitudinal Study of non-Conforming Social Reputation and Violence in Adolescents From the Gender Perspective]

Moreno Ruiz, David Neves de Jesus, Saul Murgui Pérez, Sergio Martínez Ferrer, Belén

https://doi.org/10.5093/in2012v21n1a6

Resumen

El objetivo del presente estudio fue analizar la relación existente entre la reputación social del adolescente -percibida e ideal-, y la violencia instrumental -manifiesta y relacional- en adolescentes desde una perspectiva de género. La muestra utilizada en este estudios fue de 1319 adolescentes -T1- de ambos sexos (53% chicas y 47% chicos) y de edades comprendidas entre los 11 y los 16 años (edad media 13.5; desviación típica 1.5), escolarizados en siete centros educativos de enseñanza secundaria y, de 554 estudiantes -T2- (54% chicas y 46% chicos). Los instrumentos utilizados fueron la Escala de Reputación Social no conformista de Carroll, Houghton, Hattie y Durkin (1999) y la Escala de Conducta Violenta Instrumental de Little, Henrich, Jones y Hawley (2003). A partir del análisis de los modelos de ecuaciones estructurales se obtuvo que la reputación ideal y percibida no conformista (T1) se relaciona con la reputación percibida (T2). También se observó una relación indirecta entre la reputación percibida (T1) y la reputación percibida (T2) a través de la violencia manifiesta instrumental. Se analizan estos resultados desde la perspectiva de género.

Abstract

The aim of the current study was to analyze the relationship between non-conformist social reputation (perceived and ideal) and instrumental violence (overt and relational) in adolescents from the gender perspective. The sample was composed of 1319 adolescents -T1- aged from 11 to 16 years old (Mean 13.5; S.D. 1.5) and both sexes (53 % girls and 47 % boys) in secondary school, and 554 students -T2- (54 % girls and 46 % boys). Measures were Non-conformist social reputation scale (Carroll, Houghton, Hattie and Durkin, 1999) and Instrumental violence behavior scale (Little, Henrich, Jones and Hawley, 2003). From structural equation models it was found that the non-conforming social reputation –ideal and perceived- (T1) was related with non-conforming social reputation (T2). An indirect relation was also observed between perceived reputation (T1) and perceived reputation (T2) through overt instrumental violence. Results were analyzed from a gender perspective.

Palabras clave

adolescencia

reputación social no conformista –ideal y percibida–

violencia instrumental –manifiesta y relacional–

Keywords

adolescence

instrumental violence (overt and relational)

non-conforming social reputation (ideal and perceived)

Referencias

Acoca, 1998

L. Acoca

Outside/inside: The violation of American girls at home, on the street, and in the juvenile justice system

Crime & Delinquency

1998

561-89

Medline

DOI

American Bar Association and National Bar Association, 2001

American Bar Association National Bar Association

Justice by gender: The lack of appropriate prevention, diversion, and treatment alternatives for girls in the justice system

2001

Bentler, 1995

P.M. Bentler

EQS structural equations program manual

1995

Bowie, 2007

B.H. Bowie

Relational aggression, gender and the devolpmental process

Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing

2007

107-15

Medline

DOI

Buelga et al., 2009

S. Buelga

G. Musitu

S. Murgui

Relaciones entre la reputación social y la agresión relacional en la adolescencia

International Journal of Clinical and Health Psychology

2009

127-41

Buelga et al., 2008

S. Buelga

G. Musitu

S. Murgui

J. Pons

Reputation, loneliness, satisfaction with life and aggressive behavior in adolescence

The Spanish Journal of Psychology

2008

192-200

Medline

Carroll et al., 2003

A. Carroll

S. Green

S. Houghton

R. Wood

Reputation enhancement and involvement in delinquency among high school students

International Journal of Disability, Development and Education

2003

253-73

Carroll et al., 1999

A. Carroll

S. Houghton

J. Hattie

K. Durkin

Adolescent reputation enhancement: differentiating delinquent, nondelinquent, and at-risk youths

Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry

1999

593-606

Medline

Carroll et al., 2001

A. Carroll

S. Houghton

J. Hattie

K. Durkin

Reputation Enhancing Goals: Integrating Reputation Enhancement and Goal Setting Theory as an Explanation of Delinquent Involvement

Advances in Psychology Research,

Nova Science Publishers

New York

2001

101-29

Cava and Musitu, 2000

M.J. Cava

G. Musitu

La potenciación de la autoestima en la escuela

2000

Cerezo and Ato, 2010

F. Cerezo

M. Ato

Social status, gender, classroom climate and bullying among adolescents pupils

Anales de Psicología

2010

137-44

Chesney-Lind and Belknap, 2004

M. Chesney-Lind

J. Belknap

Trends in delinquent girls’ aggression and violent behavior: A review of the evidence

Aggression, antisocial behavior, and violence among girls: A developmental perspective

Guilford Press

New York

2004

Cillessen and Mayeux, 2004

A.H.N. Cillessen

L. Mayeux

From censure to reinforcement: Developmental changes in the association between aggression and social status

Child Development

2004

147-63

Medline

Crick et al., 2002

N.R. Crick

J.F. Casas

D.A. Nelson

Toward a more comprehensive understanding of peer maltreatment: Studies of relational victimization

Current Directions in Psychological Science

2002

98-101

Crick and Grotpeter, 1996

N.R. Crick

J.K. Grotpeter

Children's treatment by peers: Victims of relational and overt aggression

Development and Psychopathology

1996

367-80

Emler, 2009

N. Emler

Delinquents as a minority group: Accidental tourists in forbidden territory or voluntary émigrés?

Coping with minority status: Responses to exclusion and inclusion

Cambridge University Press

Cambridge

2009

Emler and Reicher, 2005

N. Emler

S. Reicher

Delinquency: Cause or consequence of social exclusion?

The Social Psychology of Inclusion and Exclusion

Psychology Press

New York

2005

211-41

García et al., 2008

J.F. García

J. Pascual

M.D. Frías

D. Van Krunckelsven

S. Murgui

Diseño y análisis de la potencia: n y los intervalos de confianza de las medias

Psicothema

2008

933-8

Medline

Gifford-Smith and Brownell, 2003

M.E. Gifford-Smith

C.A. Brownell

Childhood peer relationships: social acceptance, friendships, and social network

Journal of School Psychology

2003

235-84

Hartup, 1996

W.W. Hartup

The company they keep: Friendships and their developmental significance

Child Development

1996

1-13

Medline

Hawley and Vaughn, 2003

P. Hawley

B. Vaughn

Aggression and adaptation: The bright side to bad behavior. Introduction to special volume

Merrill-Palmer Quarterly

2003

239-44

Hoff et al., 2009

K.E. Hoff

M. Reese-Weber

W.J. Schneider

J.W. Stagg

The association between high status positions and aggressive behavior in early adolescence

Journal of School Psychology

2009

395-426

Medline

DOI

Jesus, 2001

S.N. Jesus

Como prevenir o stress e resolver a indisciplina dos alunos?

2001

Keenan and Shaw, 1997

K. Keenan

D. Shaw

Developmental and social influences on young girls’ early problem behavior

Psychological Bulletin

121

1997

95-113

Medline

Larson and Richards, 1994

R. Larson

M.H. Richards

Divergent realities: The emotional lives of fathers, mothers, and adolescents

1994

Little et al., 2003

T. Little

J. Brauner

S. Jones

M. Nock

P. Hawley

Rethinking aggression: A typological examination of the functions of aggression

Merrill-Palmer Quarterly

2003

343-69

Little et al., 2003

T. Little

C. Henrich

S. Jones

P. Hawley

Disentangling the “whys” from the “whats” of aggressive behaviour

International Journal of Behavioral Development

2003

122-33

Martínez et al., 2011

B. Martínez

D. Moreno

L.V. Amador

J. Orford

School Victimization Among Adolescents. An Analysis from an Ecological Perspective

Psychosocial Intervention

2011

149-60

Moreno et al., 2009

D. Moreno

E. Estévez

S. Murgui

G. Musitu

Reputación social y violencia relacional en adolescentes: el rol de la soledad, la autoestima y la satisfacción vital

Psicothema

2009

537-42

Medline

Nelson et al., 2005

D.A. Nelson

C.C. Robinson

C.H. Hart

Relational and physical aggression of preschool-age children: Peer status linkages across informants

Early Education and Development

2005

115-39

Pereira, 2006

B.O. Pereira

Prevenção da violência em contexto escolar : diagnóstico e programa de intervenção

Infância: violência, instituições e políticas públicas

Expressão e Arte

São Paulo

2006

43-51

Postigo et al., 2009

S. Postigo

R. González

C. Mateu

J. Ferrero

C. Martorell

Diferencias conductuales según género en convivencia escolar

Psicothema

2009

453-8

Medline

Povedano et al., in press

Povedano et al., Povedano, A., Estévez, E., Martínez, B. y Monreal, M.C. (en prensa). Un perfil psicosocial de adolescentes agresores y víctimas en la escuela: Análisis de las diferencias de género. Revista de Psicología Social.

Rose et al., 2004

A.L. Rose

L.P. Swenson

E.M. Waller

Overt and relational aggression and perceived popularity: Developmental differences in concurrent and prospective relations

Developmental Psychology

2004

378-87

Medline

DOI

Salmivalli, 1998

C. Salmivalli